Why your big win felt smaller than you expected (and which layer of you to blame)
Welcome to 1-2-3 Social Psychology for Leaders—the weekly boost for leaders, so ambitious people can lead their lives and careers intentionally with confidence and energy.
Has someone forwarded you this? Subscribe here so you don’t miss the next one.
Dear First name / curious mind
A former client of mine sent me an email last week with three words: “I made it.”
She got the promotion she had been chasing for six years. The bigger the team and office, the title that she has been eying for years.
And yet, she felt nothing. Worse, she felt vaguely lost. The promotion didn’t trigger the experience she was hoping for.
She is not alone. I have heard some version of “I made it and now I feel weird about it” from at least a dozen leaders in the last few months. So today, I want to give you the framework I wish someone had handed me at twenty-eight.
1. The idea
You are not one self. You are three. And only one of them is reacting to your promotion.
What most people call “having an identity crisis” is almost never an identity crisis. It is a layer problem, and there are three layers worth knowing about.
Identity is the deepest. It answers “Who am I across my whole life?” Your values, the roles that matter, the story you are living. Slow to build, slow to change, slow to break.
Self-concept is the middle. It is what you believe to be true about yourself right now. Your strengths, your limits, your “I am good at this, not that.” This is what gets broken most of the time by a promotion. Your capability did not disappear. Instead, you no longer have clarity about what you are good at and how it connects to your new role.
Self-image is the surface. It is how you see yourself in this room, in this moment and in any situation you are in right now. This is the most reactive layer of your sense of self and the most fragile. The layer you obsess over and try to fix with a new haircut. Not being able to decide what to wear. Hiding in meetings and trying to figure out if someone is looking closely at you.
Here is the cheeky part. When leaders feel lost, they tend to do one of two things. They overhaul their entire identity (cue: midlife motorcycle, sudden silent retreat, leaving the marriage), or they try to fix it with self-image work (new glasses, executive presence coaching, or going on a diet even).
Both miss what is actually going on. Which is almost always at the self-concept layer.
Your promotion did not change who you are. It shifted what you believe you are good at because the job changed, and the old measurement points no longer apply. That is fixable. It just is not fixable by going to Bali or leaving your family (I have seen the weirdest reactions to promotions by the way).
2. Two questions to ask yourself
The next time you catch yourself thinking “I don’t know who I am anymore,” pause. Then ask:
Is this an identity question (about my whole life), a self-concept question (about my current abilities), or a self-image question (about a specific situation)?
And then: Am I trying to fix it at the right layer, or am I doing what humans do: applying the most dramatic intervention to the least dramatic problem?
Most “I need a complete life change” moments are actually “I need to update my beliefs about what I am good at” moments. This is less romantic and dramatic. But I promise it is more useful.
3. Three resources
📖 The Construction of the Self — Susan Harter. The academic anchor for the three-layer view. Dense in the best way. Read the introduction if nothing else.
🎙️ Adam Grant on identity foreclosure. In Think Again, Grant explores why high achievers struggle most when they have built their identity on a single track, like an athlete who became “a diver” rather than “someone who dives.” When the track ends, the identity does not know what to do. A short, sharp read for anyone who has felt this.
✍️ Journal prompt: Write down five things you currently believe to be true about yourself. Then write down five things you believed to be true about yourself five years ago. What changed? What did you have to let go of? What did you not even notice was gone?
As always, hit reply and tell me which layer is asking for your attention right now. Last week’s replies were among the best in my inbox in months and we had some great conversations following the email exchange. I love to connect with my readers.
See you in two weeks,
Dr. Kinga
Social Psychologist · Organizational Development Consultant · Executive Coach · Author of Be In Sync
PS: You can read more about identity on my website and in my upcoming article on positivepsychology.com
